It’s become fashionable to declare the “Marketing Funnel Model” dead.
For example, here is a post worth reading on this topic by Rok Hrastnik. There are some very good points in this post on why using a funnel to attribute media value is really a troubled idea. I was flagged on this post because it has a quote from me that seems to support Rok’s thesis about the death of the funnel model and the related idea, “Direct Response Measurement is a Wet Dream”. The quote is from a comment I made on a post by Avinash where we were discussing the value of sequential attribution models:
There are simply limits on what can be “proven” given various constraints, and that’s where experience and a certain amount of gut feel based on knowledge of customer kick in. If you can’t measure it properly, just say so. So much damage has been done in this area by creating false confidence, especially around the value of sequential attribution models where people sit around and assign gut values to the steps. Acting on faulty models is worse than having no information at all.
But none of this means the Funnel Model is dead, or that Direct Response Measurement overall is a Wet Dream. What’s (hopefully) dead is people using the funnel model inappropriately for tasks it was never designed for, in this case multi-step attribution of media value to goal achievement. On the other hand, if this specific funnel use case is what Rok was coming after, I agree, because it didn’t make any sense to use a funnel model for this idea in the first place.
Let’s unpack these ideas
Funnel thinking is based on a relatively reliable model of human behavior, AIDA. This model from human psychology does not specify tools, channels, or media. It simply says that there is a path to purchase most humans follow. That is:
A – Attention: (Awareness): attract the attention of the customer
I – Interest: (Intent) promote advantages and benefits
D – Desire: convince customers the product will satisfy their needs
A – Action: lead customers towards taking action / purchace
Example: I’m Aware of tons of products I would never buy. There are lots of products I think are Interesting but I have no Desire for. There’s a short list of products I Desire but have not Acted on. The list of products in my head worthy of purchase consideration gets smaller and smaller at each stage of the AIDA model. This is the funnel.
The AIDA funnel has not changed and it’s not dead.
It’s a model of human behavior, not media consumption.
Continue reading Marketing Funnel Not Dead, Using Funnel Model for Attribution Is