Well, we’ve been on quite a roam through the world of online advertising. We discovered how to make AdSense work, speculated on what that test means for Social Media, and spent some time running down the Relationship between Engagement and Attention.
Other than the actual test on the Lab Store, a lot of the conclusions reached throughout this trek are really speculation, because we just can’t get the information we need to do a comprehensive analysis. However, there are an awful lot of coincidences out there, and I dare say some of this speculation (thanks for the Comments to all who participated!) will probably prove true.
Regarding the Social Media business model, the speculation surrounded the idea of “the more Engaging they make it, the less Attention people have to pay to Ads”, which leads to the widely reported problems with social media ads. I asked how they could change this to create a more effective advertising environment. Barring any improvements in (what participants speculated to be) very poor ad targeting mechanisms, here’s a suggestion: Do what happens when every web ad business model fails – create vertical spaces.
The web is simply not suited to be a “mass media”, the economics don’t work. The web was born to be segmented, niched. By creating vertical social sites, you address a lot of the context problem and the display ad model begins to function more appropriately. Not to mention the traffic would be of higher quality relative to the ads.
More like a Topical Chat Board, don’t you know. Ads that make sense to the context of the visitor, for a change. Display Ads that people don’t hate or want to block. What a concept.
Hopefully, Google-Click (the merger of Google and Double-Click) will provide some real answers. I think they can, if they choose to.
I think it might even be likely they will, given the stroke of genius giving Analytics to ad clients was. The more people know, the more they spend. Transparency is king. If the display model ever wants to deliver some weight, if it is ever going to attract the big media players, they have to make these ad networks more transparent.
I still have a lot of questions about the validity of the display ad model as it is implemented today, with opaque, untargeted networks as the rule. But imagine the transparency Google-Click could bring to the whole equation with a unified cookie across Search and Display.
We could finally begin to understand the true incrementality of the relationship between Search and Display. Even more so, if Google-Click would facilitate the use of Control Groups.
We could finally address the legendary view-through measurement problem that makes me shudder every time I hear view-throughs used to bolster the value of a poorly performing display campaign. If you’re not clear on how important a common Search / Display cookie is to resolving the issue, this post by Avinash should help.
And with the kind of automation Google could bring to display, we would finally get rid of the value-destroying human overhead that cripples the display business model (placements, contracts, billing, verification, management), and then be able to price it correctly versus the value of it. Then the agencies could spend a lot more time on what they are good at – strategy, creative – and a lot less time on paperwork. Everybody wins with Google-Click.
That is, if they take the same path they took with AdWords / AdSense / Analytics. Transparency, Optimization. Display space can become PPC space – and with highly in-context spaces, vice versa.
This approach would probably bring us to a place that looks a lot more like cable network advertising does today. 100 - 200 “channels” or so of targeted, contextually-cohesive content for display to sit in.
I don’t think the web will ever be able to deliver the weight (GRP’s) of a broadcast TV network. But a cable network? Maybe.
It’s time to leave the broken offline “print model” used in online display ads behind. Because the web is different. Right?
Google-Click just might prove it.
Do you think you would get increased value from tracking Display and Search in the same interface based on the same cookie?
Perhaps this event might even ”force” a valuable unification of the Display and Search teams / agencies?
Dream On, Jim?
The next post in this series is here.